MEO Class IV · Written

Explain open loop and closed loop control systems with examples and state their merits and demerits?

Short answer

flowchart TD
    A[Open Loop] -->|No feedback| B[Fixed schedule action]
    C[Closed Loop] -->|Measures output| D[Compare to set point]
    D --> E[Form error]
    E --> F[Adjust final control element]
  • Open loop: acts on fixed schedule without checking result; no feedback
  • Closed loop: measures controlled variable, compares to set point, forms error, adjusts final control element
  • Shipboard open-loop example: starting air system (fixed timing), mechanical fuel injection timing
  • Shipboard closed-loop example: jacket water temperature control, boiler water level control
  • Open-loop merits: simple design, stable, low cost
  • Open-loop demerits: inaccurate, no correction for disturbances
  • Closed-loop merits: accurate, self-correcting, handles disturbances
  • Closed-loop demerits: complex, potential instability, higher cost

Full answer

The full answer explains each point step by step, with the regulations and figures behind it and the discussion from other candidates. It is in the MEO Class IV section of the Marine One forum, open to members enrolled for the MEO Class IV exam.